The Measurement Problem

Liquid error: internal

Video: Rats in a Maze

In this clip, Professor Dylan Wiliam shares a classic piece of psychology research. Rats were run through a maze under different conditions. One group was rewarded with food at the exit from the start and improved steadily. A second group received no reward at all, and appeared to learn very little. But a third group, given no reward for the first stretch of the experiment and then rewarded partway through, suddenly performed just as well as the first group, almost overnight.

What This Tells Us

That third group had been learning the maze all along. There was just no reward to make that learning visible, so from the outside, it looked like nothing was happening.

Wallpaper intentions are one version of this same problem, a student can copy an intention down, complete every task, and still not have learned anything durable, with nothing about their behaviour giving that away. The rats study shows it's actually broader than that: what we can observe in a lesson isn't always a reliable guide to what's been learned, whether or not the learning intention itself was ever the issue.

We'll unpack exactly why this happens, and what to do about it, in the next few lessons.

Think back to your reflection. If a student in your classroom couldn't explain what they were learning or why, despite having engaged with every task, what might that tell you about the gap between what you can see and what's actually happening?

References
Tolman, E. C., & Honzik, C. H. (1930). Introduction and Removal of Reward, and Maze Performance in Rats. University of California Publications in Psychology, 4, 257–275.

Complete and Continue